Discussion forums are ubiquitous in online education despite getting mixed reviews from students and teachers. Faculty complain of students giving only perfunctory responses, while students lament discussion questions only allow cursory answers.
The problem is the prompt is often written in language requesting a mini-academic paper or a yes-no answer rather than a real discussion. Crafting a good discussion question is tricky, but one option is to move beyond the traditional text prompt by using media such as images, videos, and podcasts. Media capture our attention in ways that text cannot. A short prompt with the accompanying video of the end of the space race can be depicted with a video clip of Neil Armstrong taking his first moonwalk. A discussion on economics can be driven with Dorothea Lange’s photo of a hungry mother with children during the Great Depression of 1936. Video and audio prompts can elicit ideas that might not have come to students with a text prompt. An instructor might also post multiple images on a topic to suggest different perspectives to get students thinking more broadly such as multiple depictions of civil rights protests by athletes throughout the 20th century.
Natural discussion happens over the last movie we saw, a new podcast we heard, or an interesting piece of news. Consider having these be the basis of online or in-class discussions too. The prompt can be a short video clip, a portion of an audio broadcast, a news story, a blog entry, an opinion piece, or even a picture. Design your discussion prompts to spark interest by having open-ended questions or ask for an interpretation of the piece.
These alternative types of prompts work best when you are trying to elicit conversation, engage students, and open broader understanding, not when you want a correct answer. Use these prompts to teach divergent thinking to encourage creativity. By the time students get to college, divergent thinking becomes secondary to getting the answer correct. But divergent thinking is key to maintaining and fostering creativity. And we all know that creativity sparks innovation. As Stacy Goodman (2015) writes, “Divergent thinking strategies offer the possibility of doing more than fostering a creative classroom environment—they can also help us better understand and appreciate difference in all areas of our students’ lives.” Alternative prompts may foster thinking from students who traditionally don’t answer the written discussion question.
Research has shown that students broaden their responses when expected to consider “multiple-perspectives, challenge assumptions, state their own predictions, and negotiate new understandings” (Williams et al., 2015). Using novel discussion prompts urge students to discuss almost any subject. But how you respond to the initial post matters too. Post your responses to further elicit deeper thought using second-level questions. That is, question your students’ initial posts to draw out further discussion. Model the type of behavior you expect in responses. Encourage others to question responses and offer differing opinions. If needed, stay with this topic before proceeding to new discussion posts.
Here are some fun examples to try in a variety of classes. Sometimes, the more obscure the prompt, the better the conversation.
- In a history class, rather than ask, “How did protests evolve during the Vietnam War era?” post Mark Riboud’s iconic photo of Jan Rose Kasmir holding a flower in front of bayonetted guns. Have students talk about the photo’s message and whether it represented the mood of the US at the time. They could even post other photos from the era and explain how their messages differ from that of Riboud’s photo in terms of either protests or war.
- In a computer class studying cybersecurity, rather than post “Why is it so difficult to prosecute international cybercriminals?” select an episode of a suspenseful podcast, such as Darknet Diaries or My Cyber Crime Story, and ask for ideas on how to stop this type of crime. Have students respond why it would or would not work. Podcasts, in general, are great sources. NPR posts podcasts on a variety of subjects. Ask students to listen and post comment on a pertinent subject.
- Bring interest into discussion boards by allowing students to post meaningful photos or videos themselves. A variation on the theme is to have students post an example and describe what it means to them with audio or video answers. For a math class, it’s easy to find patterns and repetition in nature. Instead of prompting with a photo, ask them to post one and describe the pattern.
- A trades class I work with posted a popular internet demonstration of a technique. Unfortunately, the demonstration was incorrect. Instead of pointing out the incorrect technique to the students, challenge them to find the errors and comment on how to fix them or extrapolate on the consequences.
To breed creativity in your classroom, be prepared to put in a few nontraditional discussion prompts. Expect answers to vary greatly and allow that there may not be an exact right or wrong answer. But teach the students to investigate and question why and what it means to them. Explore using audio and video for both prompts and feedback to prompts.
*Note this article was first published in Magna The Teaching Professor in September of 2022.
References
Goodman, S. (2015, August 12). Fuel creativity in the classroom with divergent thinking. Edutopia. https://www.edutopia.org/blog/fueling-creativity-through-divergent-thinking-classroom-stacey-goodman
Williams, S. S., Jaramillo, A., & Pesko, J. C. (2015). Improving depth of thinking in online discussion boards. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 16(3), 45–66.
Katherine Senko 